Elf on the Shelf Props: The Only List You Need
The handful of props that power most elf ideas, what each one is for, and a free household swap for every item, because most nights shouldn't need a shopping trip.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Links open Amazon search results (no specific product is endorsed); prices are set by sellers.
The elf-prop starter kit (covers ~60 ideas)
| Prop | Used for | Free swap |
|---|---|---|
| Mini candy canes ↗ | Ziplines, skis, fishing rods, hockey sticks, sleigh runners. | Pencils or straws |
| Mini marshmallows ↗ | Instant 'snow': bubble baths, snowball fights, igloos, sledding hills. | Cotton balls (not edible) |
| Baker's twine or ribbon ↗ | Ziplines, hanging the elf, tying scrolls and letters. | Yarn or dental floss |
| Sticky notes ↗ | Door takeovers, notes, alphabet hunts, mosaics. | Paper and tape |
| Self-adhesive googly eyes ↗ | The famous fridge takeover, candy cane reindeer, banana faces. | Draw eyes on paper dots |
| Pipe cleaners ↗ | Antlers, bird feeders, ornaments, tiny props. | Twist ties |
| Battery LED fairy lights ↗ | Glowing elf, campfires, cozy nights. LED only, never hot bulbs. | A small flashlight |
| Dry-erase or window markers ↗ | Mirror messages and whiteboard doodles that wipe off. | Sticky notes on the mirror |
Doll-size accessories (optional, but kids love them)
| Prop | Used for | Free swap |
|---|---|---|
| Mini Christmas props for dolls ↗ | Tiny mugs, books, skis and sleds sized for 10-12 inch elves. | Bottle caps, thimbles, matchboxes |
| Doll clothes for 12-inch elves ↗ | Pajamas, sweaters and hats for themed nights. | A sock cuff as a sweater |
| Mini wooden sled ornament ↗ | Sledding and sleigh scenes. | A spoon or lid |
| Doll-size sleeping bag ↗ | Sleepover and campout nights. | A fuzzy sock |
Kitchen & treat props
| Prop | Used for | Free swap |
|---|---|---|
| Ring-shaped cereal ↗ | Cereal pool, counting game, bird feeders. | Any dry cereal |
| Sprinkles ↗ | Sprinkle snow angels, snowman faces, festive breakfast. | Colored sugar |
| Hot cocoa mix ↗ | Arrival cocoa bar, marshmallow dives, movie nights. | Warm milk and honey |
| Green food coloring ↗ | North Pole breakfast (green pancakes and milk). | Spinach smoothie |
| Christmas cookie cutters ↗ | Baking station and goodbye cookie recipe. | A cup rim |
Printing & paper (for letters, notes and calendars)
| Prop | Used for | Free swap |
|---|---|---|
| Parchment paper for printers ↗ | Makes arrival and Santa letters look old and magical. | Plain printer paper |
| Christmas stationery paper ↗ | Pre-decorated borders for letters. | Our printable borders |
| Gold metallic pen ↗ | Signing letters 'from Santa' or the elf. | Any colored pen |
| Christmas stickers ↗ | Kindness bingo, classroom rewards, envelope seals. | Hand-drawn stars |
Arrival & Christmas Eve extras
| Prop | Used for | Free swap |
|---|---|---|
| Kids Christmas pajamas ↗ | Classic arrival or Christmas Eve gift. | Last year's pajamas, washed and wrapped |
| Christmas Eve box ↗ | Goodbye night: pajamas, cocoa, a movie and a book. | A shoebox wrapped in paper |
| Christmas picture books ↗ | Arrival storybook and bedtime story nights. | The library |
| Balloons (red, green, white) ↗ | Balloon-ride arrival. | Paper streamers |
| Miniature fairy door ↗ | Tiny elf door arrival. | A door drawn on brown paper |
FAQ
Do I need to buy elf props?
No. About 42 of our 172 ideas need nothing beyond household items, and the 'free swap' column shows a substitute for every prop.
What are the most useful elf props?
Mini candy canes, mini marshmallows, string or baker's twine, sticky notes and googly eyes. Together they unlock around 60 ideas.
Where can I find doll-size props?
Search for 'mini Christmas props for dolls' or dollhouse accessories. Items made for 10-12 inch dolls fit most elves.